Freedom of Speech, an inseparable Human Right
Debating Europe asked us to have an interview with Dr Azamayesh, founder of the Inter Cultural Centre. Topic of the ongoing interactive on-line Debate is “Should all radical speech be censored?” in which many followers of the discussions lead by Debating Europe respond to this question.
Here a fragment of their debate:
“To get a reply, we spoke to Dr Seyed Mostafa Azmayesh, a French-Iranian human rights activist and scholar of Gnosticism, Islam, and Christianity. What would he say?
Dr Azmayesh: Yes, freedom of speech is very, very important, and it is the right of each human being to have freedom of speech. It is an inseparable right, a sacred right.
But should we draw a line between ‘hate speech’ and ‘free speech’? If so, where should that line be drawn? That was the question from Corvus, who asks: Who gets to decide what is hate speech and what is criticism?
Dr Azmayesh: In the verses of the Quran, this teaching is [attributed] to the Prophet Mohammed, that all Muslims must respect freedom of speech according to logic and reasoning, to listen correctly and talk softly… and not try to force people into accept your reasoning… The moment that somebody thinks he is related to a supreme authority and that it is necessary to impose his will on others, then the line between freedom of speech and respect for others has be deleted. He is not within his rights. He is passing the borders of his own right and would like to impose [his view] on others.
Finally, we had a comment from Maia, who believes that the internet (including social media) is a potent tool for radicalisation. She believes that access to Facebook and Twitter should be blocked in some countries (such as Syria) to stop violent extremists like ISIS from spreading hate online. How would Dr Azmayesh respond?
Dr Azmayesh: The internet is just like an instrument. It is possible to manipulate this instrument, to handle it with bad intentions or good intentions. The internet is not important, what is important is how the internet is used. People who would like to keep society open [too often] leave the ground free for people who have bad intentions, who would like to use the internet to manipulate and brainwash people who don’t know the reality of the teachings of the Quran. We should [use the internet to] educate people better about the values of human rights and citizenship, and enter into discussions with people who need to debate and to learn to be educated.“